What matters to me today is: California’s Climate Ambitions: A Stunning Setback
Amid the relentless barrage of national and international headlines, a monumental development in California’s climate agenda has received surprisingly little attention.
On November 9, the Ninth Circuit dealt a potentially devastating blow to Governor Newsom’s signature corporate climate disclosure regime, preliminarily enjoining all climate-related financial risk disclosures under SB 261 and Scope 3 greenhouse gas disclosures under SB 253.
Why is this so significant?
California has proclaimed itself a global climate leader, seeking not merely to set an example, but to pressure governments and corporations worldwide into greater climate accountability.
Yet Scope 3 emissions—those associated with corporate supply chains, customers, and other indirect activities—can account for more than 90% of a company’s total emissions. Senator Scott Wiener, SB 253’s author, adamantly insisted upon their inclusion, even as federal regulators ultimately abandoned comparable requirements.
The Ninth Circuit concluded that compelling such disclosures likely violates the First Amendment.
While Scope 1 and 2 reporting survives for now, the court remanded the question whether Scope 3 can be severed from SB 253. If not, the entire statute could be jeopardized.
The irony? The ruling arrived just one day before California’s initial reporting deadline.
The larger question is whether California’s remaining disclosure requirements can meaningfully advance the comprehensive climate accountability its Legislature envisioned. For an administration determined to lead—and prod—the world on climate action, this is no minor judicial setback. It strikes at the heart of California’s proclaimed leadership.
That’s what matters to me today in 250 words or less. What matters to you? I’d really like to know.